Red Jacket wearing the “Peace Medal” given to him by George Washington. Portrait by Charles Bird King, ca. 1828, Colby College Museum of Art.

Red Jacket Bitters – Another Chicago ‘Indian’

Bennett Pieters & Company

13 March 2013 (R•101518)

Yesterday I started a series of posts on the Chicago “Indians” meaning primarily RED CLOUD BITTERS and RED JACKET BITTERS. Today the subject of the post is Red Jacket Bitters from Chicago.

Read More: Red Cloud Bitters – One of the Chicago ‘Indians’

Read More: He had a new variety of bitters known as Red Jacket Bitters

Read More: LEWIS’ RED JACKET BITTERS

RED JACKET

Red Jacket (known as Otetiani in his youth and Sagoyewatha (Keeper Awake) Sa-go-ye-wa-tha after 1780 because of his oratorical skills) (c. 1750–January 20, 1830) was a Native American Seneca orator and chief of the Wolf clan. He got his name from the bright red jacket he wore, which was a present from the British. He negotiated on behalf of his nation with the new United States after the American Revolutionary War, when the Seneca as British allies were forced to cede much land, and signed the Treaty of Canandaigua (1794). He helped secure some Seneca territory in New York state, although most of the people had migrated to Canada for resettlement after the defeat of the British. [reference Wikipedia]

He got his name from the bright red jacket he wore, which was a present from the British.

His talk on “Religion for the White Man and the Red” (1805) has been preserved as an example of his great oratorical style.

RED JACKET BITTERS

The first owner and the probable originator of Red Jacket Bitters was the Bennett Pieters and Company of Chicago, Illinois. They were listed in the 1860-61 city directory as Bennett Pieters, John F. Stafford and John D. Smedley at 149 Water Street.

Their bitters was patented in 1864. They apparently soon moved to 21 River Street because a Bennett Pieters and Co. advertisement, while at that address, refers to their product as Red Jacket Celebrated Stomach Bitters. The company moved to 31 and 33 Michigan Avenue in 1866, and was listed as distillers and wholesale liquor dealers.

In a Stranger’s and Tourists’ Guide to the City of Chicago, 1866 this given: “This firm had long and successfully pursued the manufacturer of the Red Jacket Bitters, and their business expanding beyond the limits of their former building, has erected and now occupies a store of palatial proportions—solid stone and brick, five stories high—“.

Back on Water Street in 1866, Edward McQuaid, Charles H. Schwab and John B. Smith were operating a wine and wholesale liquor business of their own. They added partners Leon Monheimer and P. Cavanagh in 1868, and merged with Bennett Pieters and Co. in 1869. The company was called the Schwab, Pieters and Co., and operated out of the five story building described above. Other changes occurred over the next ten years. [Dr. Richard Cannon]

There is also another Red Jacket Bitters, a round, amber, scarce bottle 10 7/8 inches tall, embossed Lewis Red Jacket Bitters, New Haven, Conn. with an Indian Head motif. PRG will develop a separate post on this unrelated brand.

Red Jacket Bitters

The Rise & Fall of Proprietor Bennett Pieters

From 1858 to 1867, says the Chicago Tribune, the name of Bennett Pieters was very well known in the city. It was connected with the Red Jacket Bitters, which were then a popular beverage, he advertised largely in the papers, and posted on fences and blank walls.

Pieters himself was a popular man among the set: he kept good saddle and carriage horses; had rooms at the Sherman house; had excellent suppers, where the guests were not called on to drink his bitters, but were regaled with champagne, which was perhaps no betters, but was certainly much more expensive, and did not openly offend any of the proprietors.

His income was a large one, but he spent it easily, and did not, like a good Chicagoan, put it in real estate. He failed to lay up treasures in these orthodox quarters, and hence when calamity came upon him he had nothing to fall back on.

In 1867 some Individual, thinking he might also make a little by going into the bitters business, began the manufacture of Red Cloud Bitters. Pieters represented this as an infringement of the right, and brought suit to have his rival enjoined. The matter was tried in the United States Court. An expert chemist analyzed Pieters’ productions, and found they consisted of poor whisky, flavored with tansy, dog fennel, jimson weed, or some other substance which possessed no special medicinal virtues. Ultimately the court decided that his right had not been invaded, and the Red Cloud and Red Jacket might have separately and independently originated bitters.

This hurt Pieters but not half as much as the analysis. People had supposed that his bitters owed their rare virtues to samples unknown to the white man, gathered at midnight in primeval forests by grim Indian chiefs, or dusky Indian girls, dark but comely, like the tents of Kedar, or the curtains of King Solomon. The secrets having been speciallly communicated to Pieters under circumstances of so private a nature that they never became public.

When the illusion was dispelled the sale of Red Jacket stopped, and Pieters’ income diminished. The less money he had the more he drank. He got involved in trouble with his partner and in 1869 departed for Washington Territory.

Returing from the west three years later, he loitered around the city doing nothing….Until last Monday, when…

The Inventor and Proprietor of the Once Famous “Red Jacket Bitters” Enlisted as
a Cavalry recruit in the United States Army…..REDUCED TO THE RANKS!

Source: New-Northwest, Deer Lodge, Montana Territory, July 20, 1872

R 19 – RED JACKET BITTERS

BENNETT . PIETERS & Co.

R 19 – RED JACKET BITTERS, BENNETT PIETERS & Co. – Meyer Collection

The Carlyn Ring and W.C. Ham listing in Bitters Bottles is as follows:

R 19  RED JACKET BITTERS

RED JACKET / BITTERS // f // BENNETT.PIETERS & CO // f //
9 1/2 x 2 3/4 (7 1/2) 1/4
Square, Amber, and Yellow olive, LTC, Applied mouth, Rare
Older than Schwab McQuaid & Co. variant
Notes: Chicago Historical Society, 1860.
Junction City Union (Kansas), 1871
Drug Catalogs: 1871 Schieffelin, 1872 Fuller & Fuller and Melliers, 1878 CB&Co., 1896-7 and 1901-2 JP&K Co.
The Chicago Directory for 1864-65 lists Bennett Pieter & Co. at 33 River St.

“RED JACKET / BITTERS – BENNETT PIETERS & CO”, (Ring/Ham, R-19), American, ca. 1865 – 1875, deep chocolate amber, 9 1/8”h, “A & CO. / NO 5” on smooth base, applied tapered collar mouth. – Glass Works Auctions

R 19.5 – RED JACKET BITTERS (Variant of R.19)

BENNETT . PIETERS & Co.

R 19.5 – Dug RED JACK BITTERS // BENNETT PIETERS & CO. – ebay

Base of a R 19.5 – Dug RED JACK BITTERS, Base embossed (A & Co NO 5) according to seller – ebay

The Carlyn Ring and W.C. Ham listing in Bitters Bottles is as follows:

R 19.5  RED JACKET BITTERS

RED JACKET / BITTERS (placed over 21 RIVER STREET, CHICAGO which is slugged out) // f  (BENNETT.PIETERS & CO is slugged out) // BENNETT.PIETERS & CO // f // // b // A & CO NO 4
9 5/16 x 2 11/16 (7 1/2) 1/4
Square, Amber, LTC, Applied mouth, Very rare
“A & Co” is Adams & Company
Halpin’s Directory for 1866 lists Bennett Pieter & Co. at 21 River St.

R 20 – RED JACKET BITTERS

MONHEIMER & Co.

R 20 – The tool top RED JACKET BITTERS – MONHEIMER & CO. – bottlepickers.com

The Carlyn Ring and W.C. Ham listing in Bitters Bottles is as follows:

R 20  RED JACKET BITTERS

RED JACKET / BITTERS // f // MONHEIMER & CO. // f //
9 1/2 x 2 3/4 (7 1/2) 1/4
Square, Amber, LTC, Tooled lip, Rare
Monheimer & Co. had been cut over Schwab, McQuaid Co.

“RED JACKET / BITTERS – MONHEIMER & Co” (with original colorful, graphic labels), America, 1890 – 1900. Golden amber, square with beveled corners, tooled sloping collar – smooth base, ht. 9 ¾”; (bottle is perfect; 90% complete front and back labels). R/H #R20. A very scarce Chicago bitters, and certainly rare with original colorful and graphic labels depicting a full-length Indian chief holding a rifle. – American Glass Gallery Auction #20

R 21 – RED JACKET BITTERS

SCHWAB, McQUAID & Co.

The Carlyn Ring and W.C. Ham listing in Bitters Bottles is as follows:

R 21  RED JACKET BITTERS

RED JACKET / BITTERS // f // SCHWAB, Mc.QUAID & Co. // f // // b // SCHWAB PIETERS / MCC & CO.
L…Red Jacket Stomach Bitters
Wholesale Liquors,  26 and 28 (added) South Water Street, Chicago, Illinois
9 3/4 x 2 3/4 (7 1/4) 3/8
Square, Amber, LTC, Applied mouth, Very rare
SCHWAB, MCQUAID & CO., Chicago, IL. 1870-1875 [pre-pro.com]

R 21.5 – RED JACKET BITTERS (Variant of R.21)

SCHWAB, McQUAID & Co.

The Carlyn Ring and W.C. Ham listing in Bitters Bottles is as follows:

R 21.5  RED JACKET BITTERS

RED JACKET / BITTERS // f // SCHWAB, Mc.QUAID & CO. // f // // b // EWM. MCC & CO.
L…Red Jacket Stomach Bitters
Wholesale Liquors, South Water Street, Chicago, Illinois
9 5/8 x 2 3/4 (7 1/4) 3/8
Square, Amber, LTC, Rare

R 21.7 – RED JACKET BITTERS (Variant of R.21)

SCHWAB, PIETERS & Co.

The Carlyn Ring and W.C. Ham listing in Bitters Bottles is as follows:

R 21.7  RED JACKET BITTERS

RED JACKET / BITTERS // f // SCHWAB, PIETERS & CO. //
9 1/2 x 2 3/4 (7 1/4) 3/8
Square, Amber, LTC, Applied Mouth, Very rare

R 23 – L…Red Jacket Stomach Bitters

Enright & Brice

R 23.5 – L…Red Jack Stomach Bitters – Meyer Collection (This is a variant as this does not have a screw cap. I am calling it R 23.5). Notice that the same Indian art is used on the label as on the lithograph art for RED JACKET CELEBRATED STOMACH BITTERS, Bennett Pieters & Co. below)

The Carlyn Ring and W.C. Ham listing in Bitters Bottles is as follows:

R 23  RED JACKET STOMACH BITTERS

L…Red Jacket Stomach Bitters
// b // CAPACITY 21 3/4 OZ.
Enright & Brice (and Sullivan) Sole Proprietors, Chicago, Illinois
9 x 3 (6/3/4)
Round, Amber, Screw cap, ABM (my example is not a screw cap)
Label: On the market since 1856 and On the Market over Fifty Years (added)
Drug catalogs: 1874 VS&R, 1878 CB&Co., 1894 M&R

Label: One tablespoon taken three times a day before meals and at bedtime is a remedy for Dyspepsia and will help relieve heaviness from the stomach and assist digestion, is also a good appetizer and a preventative of Fever and Ague. It is also a good remedy for Stomach Complaints and the formula of this was given do Dr. Chapin by the great Indian Chief ‘Red Jacket’ and by Dr. Chapin improved and brought in its present perfection and handled by him to the present manufacturers.

(Variant without RED JACKET BITTERS)

BENNETT PIETERS

21 RIVER STREET

Example of BENNETT PIETERS (can not see if CO. is there) and 21 RIVER STREET. No RED JACKET BITTERS embossed on bottle – ebay

[ebay] This auction is for a vintage circa 1864 to 1865 Bennett Pieters brown Bitters bottle. It bears the early 21 River Street address in Chicago, Illinois. The bottle is square, has concave sides and measures approx. 9 1/4″ tall and 2 7/8″ square bottom with chamfered sides.

I researched this bottle on the web and my findings were that Bennett Pieters Company first started the Red Coat Bitters sales in 1864 at the 21 River Street location in Chicago. They then moved to 31 – 33 Michigan Ave location in 1866. The bottle is not marked Bitters but the company history indicates the patent for Red Coat was awarded in 1864 so I suspect it was not on the very early bottles.

I acquired this Bitters bottle along with several other Chicago bottles that were wrapped in very old newspapers and stored in a vintage wooden crate marked Rudolph Stecher Brewing Co. in Murphysboro, Illinois.

GALLERY

Red Jacket Stomach Bitters – Private Die Medicine Stamps Essay, Scott #RS191E, Bennett Pieters & Co., 4c black, Die essay in design of the 6c stamp, on india, 162x38mm, pencil #250 in lower right corner, Year: 1862-77 – Eric Jackson Revenues

1864 Bennett Pieters & Cos. celebrated Red Jacket stomach bitters / lithograph by Edward Mendel, Chicago. Patent medicine label showing full-length portrait of Seneca chief Red Jacket holding a rifle. – Library of Congress